Home arrow Nutrition arrow Nutritional Research arrow Sometimes It Is Best Not to Reuse

Sometimes It Is Best Not to Reuse

Print E-mail
ImageBy Geoffrey R. Harris, MD

There are simple ways to avoid exposing yourself to unnecessary chemicals and bacteria during your day. People are always amazed when I tell them about this easy way to be healthier. Read on to find out how.

Did you know that you aren't supposed to reuse the plastic bottles that water and soda come in? These bottles, which typically have a plastic identification code (PIC) of 1, are usually made from a plastic called polyethylene terephthalate, PET, or PETE. PET can be difficult to clean and is somewhat porous. Bacteria can easily grow on the surface of PET containers, especially after it is covered with film from our lips and backwash. While PET is rather durable, it can begin to degrade, particularly after being exposed to heat, sunlight, or prolonged use.

Furthermore, chemicals that are used in producing plastics can migrate into foods or liquids during use. Some types of plastic (PIC #3, #6, and #7) are more likely to release harmful chemicals, while others (#2, #4, and #5) are more durable and able to stand up to repeated use. When used correctly, the amount of chemicals that leach from any plastic is minimal. However, when plastics are used incorrectly, higher levels of chemicals can be released. Generally, appropriate usage of plastic containers does not pose a significant health risk. It is the appropriate use of plastic containers that I want to focus on.

Generally, safe, reusable plastic containers should have a #2, #4 or #5. Recycle these containers when the plastic cracks, scuffs, scratches, or becomes cloudy or discolored. These containers are not designed to last forever and need to be replaced over time. Finally, avoid exposing these containers to excessive heat or sunlight.

Tips for using plastic containers:
  • Do not reuse commercial soda or water bottles. They are designed for one time use and should not be refilled. Our lips leave a film on the bottle that bacteria can thrive in and the narrow neck makes the bottle difficult to clean. If the water or soda in the container has a plastic taste or smell, then the plastic has begun to degrade, and the container should be recycled. Ultraviolet light from the sun, excessive heat, and pressure can speed up the degradation process.

  • If you use Lexan or polycarbonate bottles (#7) while hiking, do not fill with hot liquids. Clean with a mild detergent in warm water. Do not use hot water, harsh detergents, or bleach on a polycarbonate container. Never fill these containers with hot liquids. If you want to carry hot liquids like soup, tea, or coffee, get a double-walled stainless steel thermos or travel mug.

  • If you are someone who likes to have a reusable water bottle that you can refill, choose a stainless steel container like a Klean Kanteen. An aluminum bottle is okay if it has an interior enamel liner. Sigg, a Swiss company, makes reusable aluminum containers with this type of liner. Thermos makes stainless steel containers that are available at discount stores like Target or Walmart. You can also get a stainless steel travel mug with a stainless steel interior. A porcelain or glass mug is also a great way to drink water throughout your day.

  • Polycarbonate baby bottles are probably okay with cool liquids, but if you are giving your baby warm formula then look for bisphenol A-free bottles which are available at most retailers. BornFree is one brand that is very common and does not use polycarbonate.

  • Do not use plastic containers in a microwave oven or conventional oven unless the container specifically indicates it is suitable for this purpose.

  • Do not defrost meat on the plastic container that comes from the grocery. Remove the frozen meat from the container and place on a microwave safe container before defrosting.

  • Once a kitchenware plastic container becomes cracked, cloudy, or scratched, recycle it and get a new container.

  • Once a plastic container has been used to store detergents, chemicals, or non-food items, it should not be used to store food.

  • Take-away food containers are designed for one time use and should be recycled after use and not reused for storing food.

  • Remember, the best way to avoid harmful chemicals from plastics is to minimize your usage of plastic. Slowly replace your plastic storage containers and reusable water bottles with stainless steel, glass, or ceramic containers. Avoid aluminum unless it has an interior, enamel coating to prevent aluminum from leaching into your food or water.

Three other things to think about:

Water from water coolers is generally stored in large polycarbonate containers. Unfortunately, we don't often know how those containers are stored, cleaned, or treated. Furthermore, those containers are reused numerous times. Filtered tap water from home is probably safer if you are trying to avoid chemicals from plastics.

Water from commercial water bottles does not have to meet the same requirements that municipal tap water must meet. Bottled water is not controlled by the EPA, which requires tap water to be thoroughly tested and controlled. The water in your water bottle doesn't have to meet these stringent guidelines.

Finally, the environmental effect of bottled water is enormous. The plastic is manufactured from crude oil and the used containers take up a large amount of space in our landfills. When these bottles are appropriately recycled, they cannot be used to create new water bottles. The plastic is not safe enough to be used for food containers and is typically used to make plastic parking stops, park benches, or synthetic clothing like fleece. It is also frequently recycled through incineration. The most environmentally friendly approach to getting your 8 to 10 glasses of water everyday is to drink tap water or filtered tap water from a reusable glass, ceramic, or stainless steel container.

 
The concerning chemicals that can migrate from plastic containers:

Bisphenol A (BPA) has a hormone-like effect and at high levels can affect brain and reproductive development in animal studies. Human studies are lacking, but there is suspicion in the scientific community that high levels of bisphenol A can affect humans.

Styrene is a compound that causes oxidative damage to tissues and DNA. Styrene has been associated with hearing loss and nervous system diseases in humans. There may also be an association between styrene exposure and the development of pancreatic cancer.

Phthalates are another group of chemicals that mimic hormones. Phthalates are associated with lower sperm counts, DNA damage to sperm, male infertility, and developmental and reproductive abnormalities.




Plastic Identification Codes or PIC(s):

(The PIC for a plastic container can usually be found on the container's bottom inside the little recycling triangle).

#1 Polyethylene terephthalate (PET, PETE), typically found in soft drink and water bottles. It is important to recycle these containers after their initial use, mostly due to the risk for bacterial growth from reuse after improper cleaning. This type of plastic is generally more porous which affords bacteria a good place to hide. These containers can begin to degrade with prolonged use, exposure to excessive heat, ultraviolet light from the sun, and high pressure.

#2 High Density Polyethylene (HDPE), typically found in milk, juice, and reusable water bottles. This plastic is considered safe and can be reused with cool liquids. Heat, bleach, and strong detergents can damage the plastic which can lead to break-down of the containers.

#3 Polyvinyl chloride (V or PVC), typically found in juice bottles. Phthalates are used to soften this type of plastic, and certain containers can leach phthalates with prolonged or inappropriate usage.

#4 Low Density Polyethylene (LDPE), typically found in squeeze bottle, flexible container lids, and squeeze-bottles. This plastic is considered safe if used properly.

#5 Polypropylene (PP), typically found in reusable, microwaveable containers, kitchenware, and margarine tubs. This plastic is considered safe if used properly, check the container to see if it is microwave safe.

#6 Polystyrene (PS), typically found in egg cartons, Styrofoam cups, and take-home containers. This plastic can release styrene and should not be put in the microwave. It begins to degrade quickly and will become brittle.

#7 Other, including Lexan and polycarbonate (PC) containers. Polycarbonate plastic is used in baby bottles and some of the Nalgene water bottles. It is a hard plastic that resists stains and flavors. Polycarbonate plastic (Lexan) releases bisphenol A. Polycarbonate plastic will release more bisphenol A when exposed to hot liquids, chemicals, or strong detergents.

 
Tag it:
Delicious
Furl it!
Digg
Technorati
Reddit
YahooMyWeb
Home | About Us | Dr. Pratt's Blog | Contact Us | Privacy Policy
Copyright © 2006-2012 SuperFoods Partners LLC